高级医学英语阅读与写作Chapter Six
2012-07-14 11:04:45 来源:37度医学网 作者: 评论:0 点击:
Chapter Six Writing the Research Paper
I. Functions and PurposesWriting a research paper (sometimes called term paper or thesis) is much like writing an ordinary essay. Both kinds of writing involve many of the same basic process: planning a composition, drafting, revising, editing and proofreading. But writing a research paper involves more reading and note-taking because the raw material comes not from your own head but from printed sources related to the topic you are going to write on. Thus it requires much more time in specialized and concentrated reading. Putting it together should be a genuine learning experience for you. When you finish the paper, you will become an expert on the topic.
Writing a research paper, you will want to inform your reader of the subject area, seek to explain a situation, recommend a course of action or reveal the solution to a problem. To do this, you usually have a choice of two types of research papers: a survey of facts and opinions and an analysis of facts or opinions.
In a surveying paper, you need to make little attempt to interpret and evaluate what your sources say. You just present quotations and write summaries of material about your topic. This job, of course, requires a lot of skills of judgment, but the main task is not to discuss but to cite a representative sampling of facts or opinions.
In an analysis of facts and opinions, the business is much more complex. You do not simply quote, paraphrase, or summarize. But you have to do a lot of interpretation, comparison and judgment of facts or opinions you are presenting. When you are writing, you should eventually choose between surveying and analyzing because these two have their different purposes and require different techniques.
· Choosing and limiting the topic
· Gathering sources
· Writing the outline
· Writing the first draft
· Revising and finalizing the paper
In school, an assigned research paper is to be done in a limited time period and has some relationship to the course you are taking. And your instructor may provide some of the areas in the course you are taking, give you specific topic or leave the choice to you. When you get either general topic or specific topic, you should not plunge yourself into writing immediately, but evaluate and ponder over the topic. You will need to give careful thought to choosing or limiting your topic. Here are some guidelines for you to follow:
1. Choose a topic that is neither too broad not too narrow. If your topic is too broad, you won't be able to complete the paper in the limited time period or you won't be able to research because you will find too many source materials on the broad topic.
If your topic is too narrow, you won't be able to find enough information and your resources will be limited. Thus you can't develop it fully.
2. Select a topic for which there is available information. The views expressed in your research paper should usually be based on a study of a variety of sources. If one source, or none at all, is readily available, you should rethink your topic or choose another.
3. Choose a topic within the range of your abilities. No matter how interested you may be in astronomy or microbiology, you will not be able to write anything significant on these subjects if you lack the necessary knowledge.
4. Formulate your topic in the form of a question to be answered or a statement to be proved. Questions help you get the topic down to manageable size, discover its possibilities, and make it easier to focus on the specific purpose of your paper. Suppose you want to write about the problem of the world population. You could ask at least two pointed questions: What is the current situation of the growth of the world population? What is the most serious problem resulting from the growth? Either one of these could become the major question of your paper, and if you chose to concentrate on it from the beginning, your research would immediately gain a specific purpose.
The following examples are presented to show how to limit a subject until a proper topic is arrived at.
A. General: Foreign Language Education in China
Limited: English Teaching in China
More Specific: Teaching of English Reading in China
The topic chosen: How to Teach English Reading in China
B. General: Dreams
Limited: The Meaning of Dreams
More specific: The relation between Dreams and Waking Life
The topic chosen: Dreams and Waking Life
If you are a teacher of English as a foreign language in China, and you have a lot of sources available, it is appropriate to choose the first topic. If you are a medical worker or a psychologist, you will choose the second one.
Once you have tentatively chosen a topic, the next job to do is to gather sources by doing preliminary reading and taking notes because most of your views should be based on source materials.
1. Preliminary reading. The best place you should go to is the library. You can get an overview from many sources:
A textbook is the first place to look for an overview.
Standard encyclopediasoffer articles on a large number of subjects in language that a nonspecialist can understand.
Specialized encyclopediascover subjects in particular fields, such as art, music, psychology, and history.
Biographical sourcesgive brief accounts of notable figures and bibliographies are sometimes included.
Magazines or journalswith a reputation for thoughtful essays and articles are another good source for preliminary reading.
Many libraries have the Readers' Guide to Periodical Literature, the Dictionary of American Biography, the Dictionary of National Biography, the Biography Index, which are also helpful. If you are completely at a loss about where to find the reference materials, ask a reference librarian for advice or consult the Readers' Guide to Periodical Literature issued every month and cumulated annually, this is an author and subject index to articles of general interest printed in over a hundred American periodicals.
You will probably find listings in the catalog for more books on your topic than you can possibly read in the time available to you. Then you should choose the most useful books for your project: books with obvious relevance to your topic, books published recently, books that are classics in their fields, and books with bibliographies.
When you have decided which sources you want to read, have located them in the library, and have made up your cards, you are ready to examine the sources themselves and begin to read them. To do the reading well, you have to organize your reading time, read selectively, responsibly and critically.
2. Taking notes. Nobody has such a good memory that he can remember all he reads and nobody can write a good research paper without taking good notes. Also, taking notes is necessary because it makes it easier to organize your sources in order if you put each fact or piece of information on a separate card. You need to write out two kinds of card: source cards and note cards.
Source cards
The size of card normally used for this purpose is 5" ×3" (127mm ×76mm).
(1) Source card for a book.You must record the author, title, publisher and date of publication. It is also useful to record the city where the book was published. This is because the publisher may not be a well-known one, or there may be both British and American editions etc. You may also find it useful to put some kind of subject heading for filing the cards away later.
Author -------- W. BONNER ASTRONOMY ----- Subject
(optional)
Title ----------- The Mystery of the Expanding Universe
Publisher -------- Eyre and Spottiswoode
London 1964 ----------------------------------- Place and
date of
publication
(2) Source card for an article or chapter in a book.Be careful to distinguish between the author and the editor of a book. Show the difference by putting ‘ed.’ after the editor’s name. Note again that the name of an individual article is usually put in quotes but the title of the book is underlined or printed in italics.
Author ------- D. H. JONES AFRICAN HISTORY ----- Subject
(optional)
Title of _----- “Peoples and Kingdoms of the Central Sudan”
article or
chapter
Editor ------- in Roland OLIVER (ed.)
Title of ------ The Dawn of African History
book Place and
Publisher --- Oxford University Press date of
London 1961 -------------------------------------- publication
(3) Source card for a journal article. Here you must have all the details which enable you the article to be found quickly and accurately: full title of the journal, volume number, issue number, date and page reference. (Byissue we mean the copy of a journal which comes out on a particular date. Issues are collected into volumes: usually there is a separate volume for each year.) Notice that the title of the articles is put in quotes, but the title of the journal is underlined (if printed, it is in italics).
Author-- Patricia A. DENHAM LANGUAGE TESTING --- Subject
(optional)
Title -------- “Tests of aural/oral control of language”
Journal ------- Papua New Guinea Journal of Education
Volume ------- Vol. 16 no. 3 (1969) ------------------------------------ Date of
/> No. volume
or issue
/> Issue
No.
pp.11 – 16 -------------------------------------------- Page
reference
With magazines that appear weekly and with newspapers it is customary to give the exact date rather than the issue number.
Author --------- Hugh SIDEY
Title ------------ “The presidency: how much do we want to know?”
Newspaper ---- Time
Date ------------ 3 May 1976
Page ------------ p. 36
reference
(4) Other sources. Sources are not limited to books and periodicals. There are also, for example, university theses or dissertations written by students.
Author ----------- John Robert LONDON
Thesis title ------ “Mass transfer between gas bubbles and liquids”
Type of thesis --- Ph. D Thesis
University ------- Edinburgh 1968
Date of
presentation
Note cards
The size of card normally used for this purpose is 6" ×4" (152mm ×102mm).
(1) Summarizing what you read.As you take notes, you can summarize what you read by paraphrasing or putting the writer's ideas into your own words. Of course you can quote what the writer actually says but too many quotations will make readers lose track of what you are trying to say. A typical note of this kind could look like this:
Subject heading Author Page in source
Source number
(3)
Solution Piaget
p. 58
According to him, the reading can be processed through a “top-down” approach and a “bottom-up” approach. The top-down process is used to deal from the textual discourse with the main idea, word context, background knowledge, discourse analysis and the others, while the bottom-up process deals with details, syntax, word usage, idioms and the others, i.e., laying the language foundation.
How to combine the two processes?
↑
Your comment
The above note does four things with Piaget's passage.
1. A subject heading is put at the beginning. Using it, you can easily identify and place each note when you write your paper. You can also tell at a glance which function this note describes.
2. Page in source is necessary because you can refer to the original source for more information.
3. The essential part of the note is the summary which catches the important idea of the author' words usually in one sentence.
4. It records the researcher's comment. After summarizing the passage, you can draw a line and then write down one or more questions or comments.
A summary may cover more than just a brief passage, of course. Three pages can sometimes be seen in the research. But it takes a little work and thought to do that. As you summarize, you should of course feel free to quote particular words or phrases that seem important, as shown in the above sample notes: "top-down" and "bottom-up".
(2) Direct quotations from sources. Another way to take notes is to quote rather than summarize a statement which precisely and concisely expresses one of the author's fundamental views, especially when it is notably vivid or eloquent or very authoritative. The note shown here, for instance, quotes a key statement about a kind of ineffective vocabulary teaching and learning from Allan Maley, “Xanadu – ‘A miracle of rare device,’ the teaching of English in China”,Language Learning and Communication 2 (1), 1983 p.105.
Vocabulary Maley (2)
p. 105
"There is likewise a heavy load of vocabulary learning (but without the range of context which would make it useful) and an attention to the finer points of grammar, which transforms the language being taught into a series of conundrums to be solved, rather than a vehicle for communication."
_______________________________________
Is the vocabulary learning effective?
If you want to quote, you should quote accurately. Be careful to avoid mistakes of any kind. You should have quotation marks to indicate the quoted statement. If you want deliberately to omit some words not essential to the meaning of what you quote, use ellipsis dots (...). But be careful not make an omission that distorts the original. Use three ellipsis dots to indicate the omitted part, and the fourth dot is a period. Read the following sample note from Sigmund Freud's The complete Introductory Lectures on Psychoanalysis, translated and edited by James Strachery (New York: Norton, 1966).
Origins Jung(4)
P.
"One cannot afford to be naive in dealing with dreams. They originate in a spirit that is not quite human, but is rather a breath of nature .... If we want to characterize this spirit, we shall certainly get closer to it in the sphere of ancient mythologies, or the fables of the primeval forest, than in the consciousness of modern man."
_________________________________________
Compare Fromm. Is Fromm "naive"?
Compared with the original, the omitted part is “ … a spirit of the beautiful and generous as well as of the cruel goddess,” which is not important in meaning.
You have explored your subject and gathered sufficient materials about it to write a full first draft. The logical next step is to write the outline.
1. Arranging your ideas.The outline of your research paper will grow directly from the arrangement of your note cards. If you have sorted them carefully, the outline will almost write itself because the main pattern of thought or argument are presented in your mind as you sort through the note cards.
2. Combining facts with views. A paper is weak if it is crowded with facts which do not prove or disapprove a point of view. A paper is also weak if it is filled with a lot of views without any fact to support them. The weak papers bring among readers about the wonder of what all those facts are there for or doubt that they are really sound. Good papers are invariably marked by the unity of facts and ideas.
3. Writing an outline. Either a topic outline or a sentence outline is acceptable. At the beginning of the outline, there should be a statement (often in one sentence) set forth the proposition or the main point of view the paper is going to prove or analyze. This statement is called a thesis. At the end, the conclusion in this outline is necessary sometimes but tentative because you do not need to be absolutely sure of your conclusion before you start. You need a question at the beginning, but you do not immediately need the final answer. On the contrary, you should leave room for discovery as you write and the final answer or conclusion comes out at the close to your writing. (For a full discussion of vertical lists and tree diagrams, see Chapter One, p. .)
All the jobs you have done can be summed as making preparation for writing. Since you have made full preparations, you need turn the material into a coherent explanation of a topic or argument. Generally speaking a research paper consists of the following five parts: thesis and outline, introduction, body, conclusion, and notes (endnotes) and bibliography. Since the first part was discussed in the above, the page is saved for the other parts.
Writing the first draft of a research paper is much like writing the first draft of an ordinary essay. Beyond the general requirements of an ordinary essay, this paper makes its own special demands. So some suggestions are provided as follows.
1. Writing an introduction in which the subject, scope, method, and purpose of the paper are clearly announced.You have to do this in writing an ordinary paper, but the introduction to a research paper must be more formal, thorough, and rigorous. Here, for instance, is a sample introduction to the research of a very common drug problem.
Introduction
Marijuana(Cannabis sativa) is one of man’s oldest and most widely used drugs. It has been consumed in various ways as long as medical history has been recorded and is currently used throughout the world by hundreds of millions of people. A fairly consistent picture of its short-term effects on users is presented in many publications. There are, however, strongly contradictory opinions about whether the ultimate effects are harmful, harmless, or beneficial to human functioning. Many of the old reports suffered from multiple problems such as biased sampling, lack of control groups, and use of substances of unknown potency.¹However, recent scientific literature presents a clear, well-documented case.
Several factors have to be taken into consideration in order to evaluate some of the research.The first aspect is the amount of the dose of tetrahydrocannabinol (THC), the major ingredient in marijuana.²Another factor is the kind of person using marijuana. Also, the non-drug factor of setting must be considered in evaluating the results of experimental studies.³
--------------------------------
¹ Joseph Berke and Calvin Hernton, The Cannabis Experience (London: Peter Owen, 1974), pp. 14 - 15
² Stanley D. Glick and Stvetlana Milloy, “Tolerance, State-Dependency and Long-Term Behavioral Effects of THC,” in Mark L. Lewis, ed., Current Research in Marijuana (New York: Academic Press, 1972), p. 1.
³ Berke, p. 13.
These points are not going to be detailed or discussed although they have a very strong influence on an individual who smokes “pot”.
Our study may be divided into two categories; (a) at the beginning of use, and (b) when a user is into the situation. It could also be divided with reference to the level of the physical effects in man. In order to study physical effects rather than how they are produced, this paper proposes a third classification based on the duration and intensity of marijuana’s effects. Therefore, short-term and long-term or chronic effects are chosen as divisions.
…..
Notice what this introduction does. It presents some “multiple problems …” in the first introduction paragraph and points out the scope in the second paragraphs. Then it states the purpose and subject in the third paragraph: “In order to study physical effects rather than how they are produced, this paper proposes a third classification ….”
2. Make your sources work together. Writing the main part of a research paper (called the body) is largely a process of weaving your sources into a coherent whole instead of stringing your notes together. The whole is made up of quotations, your own summaries and commentary. Read the following excerption from the body of the sample reading on page X and see how well the sources are weaved together.
I. Functions and PurposesWriting a research paper (sometimes called term paper or thesis) is much like writing an ordinary essay. Both kinds of writing involve many of the same basic process: planning a composition, drafting, revising, editing and proofreading. But writing a research paper involves more reading and note-taking because the raw material comes not from your own head but from printed sources related to the topic you are going to write on. Thus it requires much more time in specialized and concentrated reading. Putting it together should be a genuine learning experience for you. When you finish the paper, you will become an expert on the topic.
Writing a research paper, you will want to inform your reader of the subject area, seek to explain a situation, recommend a course of action or reveal the solution to a problem. To do this, you usually have a choice of two types of research papers: a survey of facts and opinions and an analysis of facts or opinions.
In a surveying paper, you need to make little attempt to interpret and evaluate what your sources say. You just present quotations and write summaries of material about your topic. This job, of course, requires a lot of skills of judgment, but the main task is not to discuss but to cite a representative sampling of facts or opinions.
In an analysis of facts and opinions, the business is much more complex. You do not simply quote, paraphrase, or summarize. But you have to do a lot of interpretation, comparison and judgment of facts or opinions you are presenting. When you are writing, you should eventually choose between surveying and analyzing because these two have their different purposes and require different techniques.
II. The Writing Process
Whether you write a survey or an analysis, we suggest you follow the process though it is in some way like the process to write an ordinary essay — the process already discussed (see Chapter One, p. 5), but it has its own characteristics.· Choosing and limiting the topic
· Gathering sources
· Writing the outline
· Writing the first draft
· Revising and finalizing the paper
Choosing and limiting the topic
In school, an assigned research paper is to be done in a limited time period and has some relationship to the course you are taking. And your instructor may provide some of the areas in the course you are taking, give you specific topic or leave the choice to you. When you get either general topic or specific topic, you should not plunge yourself into writing immediately, but evaluate and ponder over the topic. You will need to give careful thought to choosing or limiting your topic. Here are some guidelines for you to follow:
1. Choose a topic that is neither too broad not too narrow. If your topic is too broad, you won't be able to complete the paper in the limited time period or you won't be able to research because you will find too many source materials on the broad topic.
If your topic is too narrow, you won't be able to find enough information and your resources will be limited. Thus you can't develop it fully.
2. Select a topic for which there is available information. The views expressed in your research paper should usually be based on a study of a variety of sources. If one source, or none at all, is readily available, you should rethink your topic or choose another.
3. Choose a topic within the range of your abilities. No matter how interested you may be in astronomy or microbiology, you will not be able to write anything significant on these subjects if you lack the necessary knowledge.
4. Formulate your topic in the form of a question to be answered or a statement to be proved. Questions help you get the topic down to manageable size, discover its possibilities, and make it easier to focus on the specific purpose of your paper. Suppose you want to write about the problem of the world population. You could ask at least two pointed questions: What is the current situation of the growth of the world population? What is the most serious problem resulting from the growth? Either one of these could become the major question of your paper, and if you chose to concentrate on it from the beginning, your research would immediately gain a specific purpose.
The following examples are presented to show how to limit a subject until a proper topic is arrived at.
A. General: Foreign Language Education in China
Limited: English Teaching in China
More Specific: Teaching of English Reading in China
The topic chosen: How to Teach English Reading in China
B. General: Dreams
Limited: The Meaning of Dreams
More specific: The relation between Dreams and Waking Life
The topic chosen: Dreams and Waking Life
If you are a teacher of English as a foreign language in China, and you have a lot of sources available, it is appropriate to choose the first topic. If you are a medical worker or a psychologist, you will choose the second one.
Gathering Sources
Once you have tentatively chosen a topic, the next job to do is to gather sources by doing preliminary reading and taking notes because most of your views should be based on source materials.
1. Preliminary reading. The best place you should go to is the library. You can get an overview from many sources:
A textbook is the first place to look for an overview.
Standard encyclopediasoffer articles on a large number of subjects in language that a nonspecialist can understand.
Specialized encyclopediascover subjects in particular fields, such as art, music, psychology, and history.
Biographical sourcesgive brief accounts of notable figures and bibliographies are sometimes included.
Magazines or journalswith a reputation for thoughtful essays and articles are another good source for preliminary reading.
Many libraries have the Readers' Guide to Periodical Literature, the Dictionary of American Biography, the Dictionary of National Biography, the Biography Index, which are also helpful. If you are completely at a loss about where to find the reference materials, ask a reference librarian for advice or consult the Readers' Guide to Periodical Literature issued every month and cumulated annually, this is an author and subject index to articles of general interest printed in over a hundred American periodicals.
You will probably find listings in the catalog for more books on your topic than you can possibly read in the time available to you. Then you should choose the most useful books for your project: books with obvious relevance to your topic, books published recently, books that are classics in their fields, and books with bibliographies.
When you have decided which sources you want to read, have located them in the library, and have made up your cards, you are ready to examine the sources themselves and begin to read them. To do the reading well, you have to organize your reading time, read selectively, responsibly and critically.
2. Taking notes. Nobody has such a good memory that he can remember all he reads and nobody can write a good research paper without taking good notes. Also, taking notes is necessary because it makes it easier to organize your sources in order if you put each fact or piece of information on a separate card. You need to write out two kinds of card: source cards and note cards.
Source cards
The size of card normally used for this purpose is 5" ×3" (127mm ×76mm).
(1) Source card for a book.You must record the author, title, publisher and date of publication. It is also useful to record the city where the book was published. This is because the publisher may not be a well-known one, or there may be both British and American editions etc. You may also find it useful to put some kind of subject heading for filing the cards away later.
Author -------- W. BONNER ASTRONOMY ----- Subject
(optional)
Title ----------- The Mystery of the Expanding Universe
Publisher -------- Eyre and Spottiswoode
London 1964 ----------------------------------- Place and
date of
publication
(2) Source card for an article or chapter in a book.Be careful to distinguish between the author and the editor of a book. Show the difference by putting ‘ed.’ after the editor’s name. Note again that the name of an individual article is usually put in quotes but the title of the book is underlined or printed in italics.
Author ------- D. H. JONES AFRICAN HISTORY ----- Subject
(optional)
Title of _----- “Peoples and Kingdoms of the Central Sudan”
article or
chapter
Editor ------- in Roland OLIVER (ed.)
Title of ------ The Dawn of African History
book Place and
Publisher --- Oxford University Press date of
London 1961 -------------------------------------- publication
(3) Source card for a journal article. Here you must have all the details which enable you the article to be found quickly and accurately: full title of the journal, volume number, issue number, date and page reference. (Byissue we mean the copy of a journal which comes out on a particular date. Issues are collected into volumes: usually there is a separate volume for each year.) Notice that the title of the articles is put in quotes, but the title of the journal is underlined (if printed, it is in italics).
Author-- Patricia A. DENHAM LANGUAGE TESTING --- Subject
(optional)
Title -------- “Tests of aural/oral control of language”
Journal ------- Papua New Guinea Journal of Education
Volume ------- Vol. 16 no. 3 (1969) ------------------------------------ Date of
/> No. volume
or issue
/> Issue
No.
pp.11 – 16 -------------------------------------------- Page
reference
With magazines that appear weekly and with newspapers it is customary to give the exact date rather than the issue number.
Author --------- Hugh SIDEY
Title ------------ “The presidency: how much do we want to know?”
Newspaper ---- Time
Date ------------ 3 May 1976
Page ------------ p. 36
reference
(4) Other sources. Sources are not limited to books and periodicals. There are also, for example, university theses or dissertations written by students.
Author ----------- John Robert LONDON
Thesis title ------ “Mass transfer between gas bubbles and liquids”
Type of thesis --- Ph. D Thesis
University ------- Edinburgh 1968
Date of
presentation
Note cards
The size of card normally used for this purpose is 6" ×4" (152mm ×102mm).
(1) Summarizing what you read.As you take notes, you can summarize what you read by paraphrasing or putting the writer's ideas into your own words. Of course you can quote what the writer actually says but too many quotations will make readers lose track of what you are trying to say. A typical note of this kind could look like this:
Subject heading Author Page in source
Source number
(3)
Solution Piaget
p. 58
According to him, the reading can be processed through a “top-down” approach and a “bottom-up” approach. The top-down process is used to deal from the textual discourse with the main idea, word context, background knowledge, discourse analysis and the others, while the bottom-up process deals with details, syntax, word usage, idioms and the others, i.e., laying the language foundation.
How to combine the two processes?
↑
Your comment
The above note does four things with Piaget's passage.
1. A subject heading is put at the beginning. Using it, you can easily identify and place each note when you write your paper. You can also tell at a glance which function this note describes.
2. Page in source is necessary because you can refer to the original source for more information.
3. The essential part of the note is the summary which catches the important idea of the author' words usually in one sentence.
4. It records the researcher's comment. After summarizing the passage, you can draw a line and then write down one or more questions or comments.
A summary may cover more than just a brief passage, of course. Three pages can sometimes be seen in the research. But it takes a little work and thought to do that. As you summarize, you should of course feel free to quote particular words or phrases that seem important, as shown in the above sample notes: "top-down" and "bottom-up".
(2) Direct quotations from sources. Another way to take notes is to quote rather than summarize a statement which precisely and concisely expresses one of the author's fundamental views, especially when it is notably vivid or eloquent or very authoritative. The note shown here, for instance, quotes a key statement about a kind of ineffective vocabulary teaching and learning from Allan Maley, “Xanadu – ‘A miracle of rare device,’ the teaching of English in China”,Language Learning and Communication 2 (1), 1983 p.105.
Vocabulary Maley (2)
p. 105
"There is likewise a heavy load of vocabulary learning (but without the range of context which would make it useful) and an attention to the finer points of grammar, which transforms the language being taught into a series of conundrums to be solved, rather than a vehicle for communication."
_______________________________________
Is the vocabulary learning effective?
If you want to quote, you should quote accurately. Be careful to avoid mistakes of any kind. You should have quotation marks to indicate the quoted statement. If you want deliberately to omit some words not essential to the meaning of what you quote, use ellipsis dots (...). But be careful not make an omission that distorts the original. Use three ellipsis dots to indicate the omitted part, and the fourth dot is a period. Read the following sample note from Sigmund Freud's The complete Introductory Lectures on Psychoanalysis, translated and edited by James Strachery (New York: Norton, 1966).
Origins Jung(4)
P.
"One cannot afford to be naive in dealing with dreams. They originate in a spirit that is not quite human, but is rather a breath of nature .... If we want to characterize this spirit, we shall certainly get closer to it in the sphere of ancient mythologies, or the fables of the primeval forest, than in the consciousness of modern man."
_________________________________________
Compare Fromm. Is Fromm "naive"?
Compared with the original, the omitted part is “ … a spirit of the beautiful and generous as well as of the cruel goddess,” which is not important in meaning.
Writing the Outline
You have explored your subject and gathered sufficient materials about it to write a full first draft. The logical next step is to write the outline.
1. Arranging your ideas.The outline of your research paper will grow directly from the arrangement of your note cards. If you have sorted them carefully, the outline will almost write itself because the main pattern of thought or argument are presented in your mind as you sort through the note cards.
2. Combining facts with views. A paper is weak if it is crowded with facts which do not prove or disapprove a point of view. A paper is also weak if it is filled with a lot of views without any fact to support them. The weak papers bring among readers about the wonder of what all those facts are there for or doubt that they are really sound. Good papers are invariably marked by the unity of facts and ideas.
3. Writing an outline. Either a topic outline or a sentence outline is acceptable. At the beginning of the outline, there should be a statement (often in one sentence) set forth the proposition or the main point of view the paper is going to prove or analyze. This statement is called a thesis. At the end, the conclusion in this outline is necessary sometimes but tentative because you do not need to be absolutely sure of your conclusion before you start. You need a question at the beginning, but you do not immediately need the final answer. On the contrary, you should leave room for discovery as you write and the final answer or conclusion comes out at the close to your writing. (For a full discussion of vertical lists and tree diagrams, see Chapter One, p. .)
Writing the First Draft
All the jobs you have done can be summed as making preparation for writing. Since you have made full preparations, you need turn the material into a coherent explanation of a topic or argument. Generally speaking a research paper consists of the following five parts: thesis and outline, introduction, body, conclusion, and notes (endnotes) and bibliography. Since the first part was discussed in the above, the page is saved for the other parts.
Writing the first draft of a research paper is much like writing the first draft of an ordinary essay. Beyond the general requirements of an ordinary essay, this paper makes its own special demands. So some suggestions are provided as follows.
1. Writing an introduction in which the subject, scope, method, and purpose of the paper are clearly announced.You have to do this in writing an ordinary paper, but the introduction to a research paper must be more formal, thorough, and rigorous. Here, for instance, is a sample introduction to the research of a very common drug problem.
PHYSICAL EFFECTS OF MARIJUANA USE
By Juan CordobaIntroduction
Marijuana(Cannabis sativa) is one of man’s oldest and most widely used drugs. It has been consumed in various ways as long as medical history has been recorded and is currently used throughout the world by hundreds of millions of people. A fairly consistent picture of its short-term effects on users is presented in many publications. There are, however, strongly contradictory opinions about whether the ultimate effects are harmful, harmless, or beneficial to human functioning. Many of the old reports suffered from multiple problems such as biased sampling, lack of control groups, and use of substances of unknown potency.¹However, recent scientific literature presents a clear, well-documented case.
Several factors have to be taken into consideration in order to evaluate some of the research.The first aspect is the amount of the dose of tetrahydrocannabinol (THC), the major ingredient in marijuana.²Another factor is the kind of person using marijuana. Also, the non-drug factor of setting must be considered in evaluating the results of experimental studies.³
--------------------------------
¹ Joseph Berke and Calvin Hernton, The Cannabis Experience (London: Peter Owen, 1974), pp. 14 - 15
² Stanley D. Glick and Stvetlana Milloy, “Tolerance, State-Dependency and Long-Term Behavioral Effects of THC,” in Mark L. Lewis, ed., Current Research in Marijuana (New York: Academic Press, 1972), p. 1.
³ Berke, p. 13.
These points are not going to be detailed or discussed although they have a very strong influence on an individual who smokes “pot”.
Our study may be divided into two categories; (a) at the beginning of use, and (b) when a user is into the situation. It could also be divided with reference to the level of the physical effects in man. In order to study physical effects rather than how they are produced, this paper proposes a third classification based on the duration and intensity of marijuana’s effects. Therefore, short-term and long-term or chronic effects are chosen as divisions.
…..
Notice what this introduction does. It presents some “multiple problems …” in the first introduction paragraph and points out the scope in the second paragraphs. Then it states the purpose and subject in the third paragraph: “In order to study physical effects rather than how they are produced, this paper proposes a third classification ….”
2. Make your sources work together. Writing the main part of a research paper (called the body) is largely a process of weaving your sources into a coherent whole instead of stringing your notes together. The whole is made up of quotations, your own summaries and commentary. Read the following excerption from the body of the sample reading on page X and see how well the sources are weaved together.
Introducing sentences
Source 1 in paraphrases
Explanation
Comment
Introducing another idea
In ancient times, dreams were thought to come from God or some mysterious source outside the dreamer. In modern times, the search for their origin has focused much more on the mind and natural experience of the dreamer than on anything supernatural. Erich Fromm, for instance, says that nearly every dream we have is prompted by our reaction to some occurrence of the preceding day.¹ I suspect that each of us has had such dreams. I myself have dreamed about driving a car across the ocean soon after a day at the beach, and about getting swallowed up by a lion after a visit to the zoo. But not every dream can be readily traced to an experience of the previous day, and even if it could. The memory of an experience cannot explain why and how a dream transformed it, why and how a day at the beach becomes a drive across the ocean. The gap between dreams and remembered experience is sometimes so
Source 2 in quotation
wide, in fact, that at least one modern psychologist locates their origin in something outside of experience. Carl G. Jung writes: “……”²
Source 1 in paraphrases
Explanation
Comment
Introducing another idea
In ancient times, dreams were thought to come from God or some mysterious source outside the dreamer. In modern times, the search for their origin has focused much more on the mind and natural experience of the dreamer than on anything supernatural. Erich Fromm, for instance, says that nearly every dream we have is prompted by our reaction to some occurrence of the preceding day.¹ I suspect that each of us has had such dreams. I myself have dreamed about driving a car across the ocean soon after a day at the beach, and about getting swallowed up by a lion after a visit to the zoo. But not every dream can be readily traced to an experience of the previous day, and even if it could. The memory of an experience cannot explain why and how a dream transformed it, why and how a day at the beach becomes a drive across the ocean. The gap between dreams and remembered experience is sometimes so
Source 2 in quotation
wide, in fact, that at least one modern psychologist locates their origin in something outside of experience. Carl G. Jung writes: “……”²
You have to have many quotations in your paper. When you quote anything, ask yourself why you are quoting it. The trouble with many student research papers is that they are not much more than a collection of quoted passages or that they are just stringing their notes or quotations together. Thus, the author will not get much credit for papers full of long quotations. As for the length of a quotation, quote as much as you need to make your point, and no more. Bear in mind that quoting a word or phrase is a way of emphasizing it. If a phrase is buried in a long quotation, you will lose the emphasis.
(1) Using quotations
If you want to quote, you have to put quotation marks exactly around the beginning and the end of the source immediately followed by a footnote numbered. At the bottom of the page or at the end of the paper, a footnote is given. But you must note that quoted material should not take up more than one-fifth of the total research paper.
And each quotation should not take up more than four lines. Long quotations (more than four lines) do not have quotation marks around them in a research paper. They should be single-spaced and indented five spaces from the left and right margins of the text. A colon is used to introduce a long passage as in the following example:
…… The gap between dreams and remembered experience is sometimes so wide, in fact, that at least one modern psychologist locates their origin in something outside of experience. Carl G. Jung writes:
One cannot afford to be naive in dealing with dream. They originate in a spirit that is not quite human, but is rather a breath of nature. If we want to characterize this spirit, we shall certainly get closer to it in the sphere of ancient mythologies, or the fables of the primeval forest, than in the consciousness of modern man.²
Quotations should be smoothly incorporated into the paper by using transitional phrase or sentence, such as:
as X states
declared
wrote
commented
noted
(2) Paraphrasing
In most instances, the best way to incorporate source material into your paper is by paraphrasing, that is, restating in your own words what is stated in the source. This can also be done by using a transitional phrase or sentence, such as:
According to X,
It is stated by X that
It is noted by X that
For example:
It is commented by Maley that the foreign teacher is apt to find this puzzled concern with this detailed language somewhat distressing since for him, reading is nothing else but teaching students to learn from textbooks efficiently and to use what they learn in their business.¹
Paraphrases, like quotations, must be footnoted as the above.
But quoting is not the only way of using materials in your notes. You can write summaries, restatements or paraphrasing the quotations. When you write summaries, you can produce much more effective passages.
After a quotation, a commentary is usually given, but your commentary is usually as long as the quotation. If a lengthy passage is important enough to be quoted in full, you ought to have some important thing to say about it. If you don't have much to say about it, don't quote it, or at all. A long quotation followed by a single sentence of commentary usually tells the reader that the writer is dozing his or her way through the paper.
3. Always explain the relation between the statements and in an analysis, also evaluate the statements. Unless it is immediately obvious, you should tell the reader how one statement reinforces, qualifies, or contradicts another. In an analysis, you should evaluate the statements you cite, especially when they represent conflicting points of view. If you don't evaluate the statements and choose between them, you will not make your viewpoint clear, and you will fail to present an argument in the paper as a whole.
4. In a survey, end by summarizing the various viewpoints you have considered; in an analysis, end by stating your own viewpoint and the
-------------------------------
¹Allan Malley. 1983. “Xanada – ‘A miracle of rare device’: the teaching of English in China”, A language Learning and Communication 2 (1) p. 104.
reasons for it.
A Survey
If you set out to make a survey of the various opinions about the nature of dreams, you should end by summarizing or broadly categorizing them:
…….
A survey of theories about dreams, then, shows that there is little agreement and much disagreement about where they come from, what they mean, and what purpose they serve. Jung locates their origin in the unconscious and in ancient archetypes; others, such as Fromm, regard them as the product of experiences in our waking life. Virtually all commentators on dreams agree that they mean something, but what they mean is disputed. While Freud says that a dream is the fulfillment of a wish, others see it as the result of a purely physical activity — of rapid eye movement during certain phases of sleep. Finally, while Jung regards dreams as “message carriers” from the instincts to the conscious mind, others argue that dreams solve specific problems and enable us to cope with the waking world. I can only conclude that dreams are — and will probably remain — a subject of debate and dispute.
An analysis
By the contrast, the writer of analysis should end by making his or her view explicit or by giving the reason for it. The following conclusion emphasizes the writer's viewpoint:
PHYSICAL EFFECTS OF MARIJUANA USE
By Juan Cordoba……
Conclusion
While much has already been learned about the acute physiological effects of Cannabis, much remains to be learned. It is also important to understand the possible influence of other constituents of Cannabis which may not in themselves be psycho- or physical-active but may nevertheless influence the action of those constituents which are.
In spite of the increase of marijuana research papers in the last 10 years, some actions of marijuana are incompletely understood and their possible significance for health cannot at present be evaluated. These areas are discussed under the classical organ systems approach commonly used in medicine. Cardiovascular systems, gastrointestinal function, liver function, neuroendocrine effects of marijuana, and lung function are, from my point of view, the main areas to be investigated.
Revising and Finalizing the Draft
Revision
When the first draft of the research paper is produced, the next important job is revision because no one is likely to work very well on his or her first draft without revision. Revision gives you the chance to strengthen your organization, to enliven your sentences, and to clarify or eliminate confusing words, phrases or construction. Since second looks often lead to second thoughts, it also lets you find some new ways to making a point.
Revision can be done in two general divisions: check overall organization and check specific points, which are again divided into eight steps.
1. Check overall organization
Step 1 Check the main parts of the paper
Revision lets you make sure that each part of the paper goes well with the others and that all of them work together toward your purpose. You will check if the introduction is general and concise enough as to introduce the main idea, purpose, and development and so on; if the development paragraphs support the main idea fully; and if the conclusion paragraph(s) is powerful and conclusive enough as to make a deeper impression on your readers or summarize your idea more emphatically.
Step 2 Check the topic sentence of each paragraph
All the topic sentences should be closely related to the main idea introduced in the introductory paragraph(s) and control the development of the paragraph. Check if the topic sentence is general enough as to control the whole paragraph, if it is interesting to attract the reader, and if it indicates the development.
Step 3 Check for unity and coherence
Check the organization, content, transition, style and tone of the paper (essay) as a whole. Look for a line of thought from beginning to end, reliable generalization support by specific details, and a consistent point of view. Consider the following questions:
· What is the general idea? Does the main point of each paragraph follow the general idea and from the main idea developed in the preceding one?
· Are the shifts in topic from one paragraph to the next marked by clear transitions?
· Does a paragraph digress from the line of thought or work against it?
· Are your style and tone consistent or do they suddenly change?
· Are any points discussed at much greater length and others or equal importance? Is any of the commentary redundant? (For the detail, read Chapter Five.)
Step 4 Check quotations and citations
If you quote one or more sources, ask yourself the following questions:
· Are there too many quotations? Do they crowd out your own statements, or substitute for them? Could you summarize or paraphrase any of them instead of quoting directly?
· Is each quotation accurate? Did you copy it correctly? If you omitted some words, did you mark the omissions properly, with ellipsis dots?
· Have you introduced each quotation clearly and with correct punctuation?
· Have you clearly acknowledged every written source by footnoting or endnoting?
2. Check specific points
Step 5 Check for sentence errors
· Are all your sentences grammatically acceptable, have you written some sentence fragments?
· Does every pronoun refer clearly to its antecedent?
· Is the parallelism in any sentence faulty?
· Does every verb agree with its subject?
· Do you shift tense anywhere without a good reason? Are you unsure about the sequence of tenses in any of your sentences?
Step 6 Check spelling, syllabification and capitalization
Most writers misspell very often in the first draft. In revision, you have to pay special attention to some of the spellings.
· Are the word endings-es, -'s, and -s' used correctly?
· Are your own spelling demons now spelled correctly?
· Are you unsure about whether or not to syllabify a word or to capitalize certain words?
· Have you checked in the dictionary whenever you aren't sure of a spelling or syllabification?
Step 7 Check the choice of words
· Did you choose the right word and the right verb pattern in a context?
·Does any word have the wrong denotation for its context?
· Does any word have the wrong connotation for its context?
· Is your language predominantly general and abstract? Can you make it more specific and concrete?
· Can you make your language more figurative?
· Are any sentences cluttered with words you don't need?
Step 8 Read the paper aloud
As a final check, read the entire draft aloud. If anything sounds wrong, see whether you have overlooked part or all the previous steps.
Typing and submitting your paper
Most instructors will expect you to type your research paper in a typewriter or produce your paper in a computer.
1. Use the right paper. If you type, use medium-weight typing paper of standard size (8.5 by 11 inches). If you put it in a computer, use the computer paper to print it.
2. Leave adequate margins of 1.5 to 2 inches on each side and doublespace the material. Read the format in the following pages
3. Number your pages in the upper right-hand corner, except for page one; this page is not numbered. Begin with number 2 on the second page. The title page and the table of contents are not numbered.
4. Give your paper a title. If you are not required to use a separate title page, type the title of your paper, your name, name of number of the course, your instructor's name and date you hand in the paper as shown in the first format. If you do use a separate title page, follow the second format in the following and repeat the title on the first page of text.
Format with title on first page of text
Triple space
Aaron He
Professor J.S. DeCarrico
Ling. 486 --1"-- Dec. 21. 1990
Triple
space
Prospective Renewal of our ESL Teaching
5-space Triple
indentation space
My visit to the U.S.A. makes me fully aware what
the language ability of application is and how big the gap
--1"-- of Chinese students studying here is in language applications. ---1"---
The general impression is that they know a lot about English
but apply little of it, and they score high but do little with it.
Format with separate title page
4"
Prospective Renewal of our ESL teaching
Quadruple
space
Aaron He Quadruple
space
Professor J. S. DeCarrico
Ling. 486 Double
Dec. 21. 1990 space
First page of text following separate title page — note repetition of the title
Prospective Renewal of our ESL teaching
Triple
space
My visit to the U.S.A. makes me fully aware what
the language ability of application is and how big the gap
-1"-- of Chinese students studying here is in language application. --1"--
The general impression is that they know a lot about English
but apply little of it, and they score high but do little with it.
Second and succeeding pages of text
Page no.
Triple
space
2
Aaron He Single
Ling. 486
Triple
space
-- 1"-- to the public that no time should be lost to make --- 1"---
III. Format of Writing References
·Writing bibliography
·Writing a footnote
·Placing first and later footnotes
·Writing an endnote
Writing bibliography
A bibliography is a list of books and articles which serve as the sources of information for your paper. Bibliographies are of two kinds: the working bibliography and the final bibliography. The former is a set of cards listing any sources which might be useful to you; the latter is a list of sources you actually use in writing the paper and is attached at the end of your paper in an alphabetical listing.
In writing the final bibliography, the following information could probably be included though there is some variation in the requirements of bibliographical entries:
(1) author's name ` (2) date of publication (year)
(3) title of work (4) place of publication
(5) name of publisher
Smith, John. 1972. Understanding English. London: Berelman.
(1) ↓ ↓(2)↓ (3) ↓(4) ↓ (5) ↓ comma period period period colon period
Certainly entries vary a little with your sources which may come from a book, an anthology, a magazine or a journal. So the entries may be written in somewhat different order like this:
(1) A book with one or two authors
Chomsky, N. 1957. Syntactic Structures. The Hague: Mouton.
Hurford, J.R. & Heasley, B. 1954. Semantics: a Course book. London: Cambridge University Press.
(2) A book with two or more authors
Quirk, R. et al. 1973. A Grammar of Contemporary English. London: Longman.
(3) A book with an editor (anthology)
Allen, H. B, and Underwood, G. N, eds. 1971. Readings in American Dialectology. New York: Appleton-Century-Grofts.
(4) A book of editions other than the first
Greenberg, J. 1966. Universals of Language. 2nd edn.
(5) A translated book
Boll, Heinrich. 1974. End a Mission, Trans. Leila Vennewitz. New York: McGraw-Hill Book Company.
(6) Work of more than one volume
Adams, W. E. and others, eds. 1968. The Western World: To 1770. 2 vols. New York: Dodd, Mead and Company.
(7) A book in which one chapter is your source
Lees, R. B. 1970. Problems in the grammatical analysis of English nominal compounds. In Bierwisch & Heidolp (eds), 174-86 pp.5, 160
Pimsleur, P. 1966. “Testing Foreign Language Learning,” Trends in language Teaching. ed. A. Valdman. New York: McGraw.
(8) A journal
Norris, William. “Advanced Reading: Goals, Techniques, Procedures,” TESOL Quarterly, IV: 1 (March, 1970), 187-193.
More remarks:
A. In the item of name of author, when writing the bibliography, the family name always comes before the first name with a comma separated. When writing a note or references, the family name has to come after it.
B. About the title: The title of a book is indicated by being underlined when handwritten or typed and being italicized when printed.
C. About chapters and articles in a book: They are quoted and ended in a comma within the quotation marks, as in (7) above.
D. The title of the journal is underlined or italicized just as the title of a book is underlined above, as in (8). The Roman number refers to the volume and Arabic number to the issue number, as in (8).
E. Some abbreviations:
et al: and others trans: translation or translated
ed (eds or edd. for pl.): editors edn: edition
F. The orders and items for the entry vary from books to books and from writers to writers. e.g.
(1) Smith, John. Understanding English. London: Berelman. 1972.
(2) Quirk, R., Greenbaum, S., Leech, G. and Svartvik, J. (1972) A Grammar of Contemporary English. London and New York.
In the above examples, the date of publication comes either at the end, as in (1) or between the name of the author and the title of a book and is parenthesized, as in (2). all the authors are listed instead of using “et al”; the title of the book is followed by a comma instead of a period and no publishers are listed.
The above examples listed are samples — standard forms and therefore universally acceptable though there are a few variations of bibliographies.
Writing a footnote
A footnote tells the exact place of your source for a quote or borrowed information for your paper and is written at the bottom of the page. Sometimes it is also listed consecutively at the end of the paper. A footnote is necessary to show the author's intellectual honesty: you don't want to give the impression that another arthur's ideas are your own; to support the accuracy of your paper; the readers will have more confidence in your ideas if they are backed up by a citation from an authority; and to help the readers of your paper: they can consult the information noted by you and develop their own ideas.
The footnote references should include the necessary elements in the following order:
For books:
John Smith, Understanding English (London: Berelman, 1972), p.12.
↓ ↓ ↓ ↓ ↓ ↓ ↓
1st last title of the book place name year page
name underlined or of pub- of pub- of number
italicized lication lication pub-
lication
comma brackets colon comma comma
period
For periodicals:
M. Falcoff, “Why Allende Fell,” Commentary, July 1976, p. 3.
↓ ↓ ↓ ↓ ↓
1author title of article name of the month and page
periodical year of number
underlined publication
or italicized
comma in quotation comma comma comma period
marks
Place first and later footnotes
There are two ways of citing sources in a paper with notes: the first reference to a source and another for all later references. The footnote for the first reference provides extensive information and the later references may be placed within the text or in the footnotes or the endnotes.
For example:
First reference
1 Allen Maley, “Xanadu — ‘A miracle of rare device’: the teaching of English in China”,Language Learning and Communication 2 (1), (1983), p. 104.
This book is cited hereafter as Maley.
Your later reference may be placed within the text:
.... What we have done is lead them “to work hard at digging a hole. But all too often, it is dug in the wrong place” (Maley, p. 105).
The note within the text includes the name and the page number and sometimes the name and the year of publication.
Or in the footnotes or endnotes:
.... What we have done is lead them “to work hard at digging a hole. But all too often, it is dug in the wrong place.”²
Later reference
¹Allen Maley, “Xanadu —‘A miracle of rare device’: the teaching of English in China”, Language Learning and Communication 2 (1), (1983), p. 104. (first reference)
² Maley, p. 105. (later reference)
or:
² Ibid, p.105.
Ibid. is the abbreviation for the Latin word ibidem, meaning that the reference comes from the same source and same page number. If the page number is different, state it after ibid as indicated above. (For the detail, read Chapter 8.)
An easy way to find out the form for the type of footnote you want is to look at the footnotes in one of your sources. The footnotes can be numbered in one of the three ways:
· Continuous orderfor each page
· Continuous order for each chapter
· Continuous order throughout the paper
Footnotes can be listed at the bottom of each page or at the end of the paper on a separate page, before the bibliography.
A footnote contains essentially the same information as a bibliographical entry; however, it specifies the page or pages where you find the information, the full name of the author is in natural order and the place of publication and the publisher's name are optional. Sometimes you can quote a short quote and set it off with or without quotation marks in the footnote. Usually a short line across part of the page sets apart from your text.
Footnote: Continuous order throughout the page
…….
In the vast majority of cases, these infixes occur immediately before the syllable of the base that bears the lexical stress; thus while licketyfucking-split¹³ is acceptable, leckfuckingetysplet is not. Other examples which fit the standard pattern are albloodymighty, imfuckingpossible, kangabloodyroo and propafuckingganda.14Handibloodycap,15 dimfuckingwit and atmosfuckingphere are rather odd because they tend to require the re-assignment of stress to the final syllable, although it would normally fall on the first syllable of the base.…
-------------------------------------
13 William Goldman. 1976. Magic. London: MacMillan, p. 12.
14 All cited by MacMillan (1980).
15 Ibid. pp. 233. 167. (Ibid. is the abbreviation for Latin word ibidem meaning that the reference is the same as that cited just before.)
本文来自37度医学网,http://www.37med.com,转载请注明出处。
上一篇:高级医学英语阅读与写作Chapter Five
下一篇:高级医学英语阅读与写作Chapter Seven
论坛新帖
频道总排行
医学推广
频道本月排行
热门购物
评论排行
- 2011年临床执业医师考试实践技能真...(13)
- 腋臭手术视频(11)
- 2008年考研英语真题及参考答案(5)
- 节食挑食最伤女人的免疫系统(5)
- 核辐射的定义和单位(5)
- CKD患者Tm与IMT相关(5)
- 齐鲁医院普外科开展“喉返神经监护...(5)
- windows7激活工具WIN7 Activation v1.7(5)
- 正常微循环(5)
- 美大学性教育课来真的 男女上阵亲...(4)